Wednesday 23 November 2011

3. Proposal on Rotary Foundation Scholarship restrictions


PROPOSED RESOLUTION

To allow Rotarians; honorary Rotarians; employees of a club, district, or other
Rotary Entity or of Rotary International; or spouses, lineal descendants (child
or grandchild by blood, legal adoption, or marriage without adoption), spouses
of lineal descendants, or ancestors (parent or grandparent by blood) of persons
    in the foregoing categories to be eligible for Rotary Foundation Scholarships if they  
meet all of the other requirements.
Proposed by the Rotary Club of Comox.
Endorsed by District 5020 through email balloting.
WHERAS, current Rotary Foundation qualifications for Rotary Foundation  Scholarships currently restrict Rotarians, Rotarian family members, Rotarian associates, and Rotarian employees from an award of scholarship, and
WHEREAS, part of the Four Way Test states, “Is it Fair to All concerned”, and
WHEREAS, another part of the Four Way Test states, “Is it Beneficial to All concerned, 
IT IS RESOLVED by Rotary International that the Board of Directors of Rotary International consider requesting the Trustees of the Rotary Foundation to amend Section 7.030 of the current Rotary Foundation Code of Policies and Section 9.3 of the Rotary Foundation Bylaws to eliminate all restrictions from Rotary Foundation Scholarships against Rotarians, their descendants, their relatives, associates, and employees.  
The proposed change to page 124 of the 2010 MOP is as follows:

Qualifications
A candidate for a Rotary Foundation Scholarship must demonstrate
outstanding potential as an ambassador of goodwill, which can be
measured through leadership skills, communication skills, and commitment
to service. Applicants must have completed at least two years of university
or college coursework, or must have a secondary education and have been
employed in a recognized profession for at least two years when the scholarship
begins. Applicants must be citizens of a Rotary country. Candidates cannot
be Rotarians; honorary Rotarians; employees of a club, district, or other
Rotary Entity or of Rotary International; or spouses, lineal descendants (child
or grandchild by blood, legal adoption, or marriage without adoption), spouses
of lineal descendants, or ancestors (parent or grandparent by blood) of persons
in the foregoing categories. Initial application must be made through a Rotary
club in the applicant’s legal or permanent residence or place of full-time study
or employment.

4 comments:

  1. As the Ambassadorial Scholarship program stands at present, it is
    1. Fair to All Concerned
    2. Beneficial to All concerned.

    If the changes are made allowing the suggested group of people to apply for this scholarship, how will Rotarians insure, in the eyes of all, that the program remains without bias?

    Jp

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think changing the program to include Rotarians and those associated with them will make it harder for the decision makers to make their selection. For this reason and for the reasons Joan mentioned, I think it should stay as it is.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree. There is no question that Rotarians have integrity and we want to keep it that way. Including our rellies might create the perception of bias, whether it exists or not.

    ReplyDelete